Inter Miami’s defence of the MLS title is in immediate danger after a 3-0 defeat by Columbus Crew left Lionel Messi and his team needing victory in the second game of their best-of-three first-round series.
The result was a particularly damaging one for the reigning champions, reviving concerns from their previous play-off campaign, where regular-season form failed to translate into success in the knockout stages.
Columbus made the ideal start when Gonzalo Tapia converted a penalty in the ninth minute, putting Inter Miami under early pressure.
Inter Miami created opportunities in response, including several involving Messi, but Columbus goalkeeper Patrick Schulte produced a series of important saves. The Argentina forward was unable to find the net despite repeatedly threatening the home defence.
The visitors’ task became significantly harder in the 36th minute when Gonzalo Lujan was sent off, leaving Inter Miami to play the remainder of the match with 10 men.
Columbus took full advantage after the interval. Taha Habroune doubled their lead in the 52nd minute before Tapia scored his second goal eight minutes later to complete a decisive victory.
The statistics reflected Columbus’ greater efficiency. Both sides registered nine shots, but the Crew controlled about 60% of possession compared with Inter Miami’s 40%. Inter Miami also committed 22 fouls as they struggled to cope with the numerical disadvantage.
Inter Miami still have a route through
Despite the three-goal margin, Inter Miami do not need to overturn the deficit in the conventional sense. A win of any scoreline in the return match would level the series at one victory apiece and force a deciding third game.
That is because the opening round of the 2026 MLS play-offs uses a best-of-three format rather than an aggregate-score system across two legs. The first team to record two wins progresses.
There are no drawn matches under the format. If the scores are level after 90 minutes, the winner is decided by a penalty shootout, with no extra time.
Inter Miami must now win away from home in the second match, scheduled for 27 November at Columbus’ stadium in Ohio. Victory for Messi and his team would send the series back to Inter Miami for a decisive contest on 1 or 2 December, according to the published schedule.
A second defeat would eliminate the champions and end their hopes of retaining the title.
Messi enters the play-offs after an outstanding individual MLS season. He won the 2026 Golden Boot after scoring 26 goals in the regular season and supplying 17 assists, becoming the first player in league history to claim the award in consecutive seasons.
He also joined a select group of multiple Golden Boot winners, but his latest performance highlighted the gap between individual achievement and collective success. Messi came close against Columbus, only to be denied by Schulte, including from close range and a direct free-kick.
Inter Miami were also eliminated in the first round by Atlanta United in 2024. Columbus, meanwhile, ended the regular season strongly with six successive victories after recovering from a difficult position in the Eastern Conference standings. They now need one more win to remove the holders from the competition.