Bayern Munich’s controversial decision to sell Matthijs de Ligt and keep Dayot Upamecano has increasingly appeared to vindicate Vincent Kompany, with the Dutch defender now facing an uncertain future at Manchester United.
The choice sparked anger among Bayern supporters in 2024, prompting 71,840 people to sign an online petition calling for De Ligt to remain. Since then, the two defenders’ careers have moved in sharply contrasting directions.
When Kompany became Bayern manager in the summer of 2024, he had five central defenders to consider: Upamecano, Min-jae Kim, De Ligt, Eric Dier and new signing Hiroki Ito. One had to leave, and reports suggested Upamecano was initially the player the club was prepared to sell.
Kompany disagreed. He viewed the France international’s pace and physical qualities as particularly suited to the tactical approach he wanted to establish at Bayern, despite criticism of Upamecano’s repeated errors and injury problems.
De Ligt subsequently joined Manchester United in mid-August 2024 for 45m euros. Many Bayern fans regarded the sale as a serious mistake, given his performances for the club and the concerns surrounding Upamecano. The German publication Spox reported on the reaction.
De Ligt had arrived from Juventus in the summer of 2022 for 67m euros after emerging as one of European football’s leading defensive talents at Ajax. Signed during Julian Nagelsmann’s time as Bayern manager, the 22-year-old quickly made an impact.
He finished second behind Jamal Musiala in the supporters’ vote for Bayern’s player of the season in his first campaign, then continued to establish himself as one of the team’s most dependable defenders. His leadership, fighting spirit and commitment made him popular with the supporters.
The petition, titled “Keep De Ligt! We want De Ligt!”, urged Bayern to reverse the transfer and warned that selling him would prove a costly error. De Ligt said the backing “touches my heart”, but the club proceeded with the move.
Upamecano gradually justified Kompany’s faith, becoming a regular alongside Kim and later forming an effective partnership with new arrival Jonathan Tah at the start of the 2025-26 season. Bayern rewarded him with a contract extension until 2030 and a signing-on payment estimated at about 20m euros at the beginning of 2026.
De Ligt, meanwhile, suffered a back injury in autumn 2025 after a period of improved form. Ruben Amorim, then Manchester United manager, initially described it as “a minor issue”, but several setbacks kept the defender out for months. He underwent surgery in May, ending his season and damaging his hopes of featuring for the Netherlands at the World Cup.
He returned in late October against Como Calcio in the Champions League, a match Manchester United lost 4-1, but made only one further brief appearance in the competition. His last Premier League match came on 30 November 2025.
Competition for his place has also intensified. Michael Carrick preferred Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez, while De Ligt was overlooked when Martinez was suspended, with right-back Leny Yoro and 20-year-old Ayden Heaven used at centre-back instead.
Carrick was dismissed during the international break and replaced by Mauricio Pochettino. De Ligt, contracted until 2029, has never played two consecutive seasons as a regular under the same manager and is now considered a possible departure in January or at the end of the season.
Manchester United great Gary Neville has said: “De Ligt must leave.” Inter Milan and Besiktas are reportedly interested in the 27-year-old, whose future at Old Trafford remains unclear.