Thousands of diplomats, officials and campaigners are meeting in Turkiye for the 31st United Nations climate summit, where the familiar call for global net zero emissions by 2050 is expected to dominate discussions.
But the financial cost of that target, and the value of the climate benefits it would deliver, have rarely been examined at the United Nations’ climate conferences.
An analysis of Ghana’s position suggests reaching net zero by 2050 would cost the country substantially more than the climate damage it would prevent.
The calculations are available through NetZeroCostBenefit.com, a website created to show the projected costs and temperature effects for Ghana and other countries or groups of countries pursuing the target.
It uses MAGICC, the climate model used in United Nations climate reports, to convert national emissions commitments into projected global temperatures in 2100.
The cost of reaching net zero
The economic estimates are based on United Nations surveys of economic models, while the damage projections come from two recent assessments of the cost of global warming.
For its latest report and subsequent updates, the climate panel collected almost 1,000 estimates of the economic impact of climate policy. Most do not model net zero by 2050, because of the difficulty and expense involved.
Only three models begin with current emissions and reach net zero, rather than assuming reductions started years earlier. They estimate that global net zero would reduce global GDP by between 3% and 19% in 2050 as higher energy costs restrict economic growth.
The website uses the midpoint of those estimates, putting the loss at 7.2% of GDP in 2050 compared with current policies.
The projected benefits are drawn from work by climate economists Richard Tol and William Nordhaus, the only climate economist to have won the Nobel Prize in economics.
Based on the warming expected under current policies, their estimates suggest climate change would reduce global GDP by 1.8% to 2.8% by 2100.
The analysis argues that net zero would prevent only part of that damage, and that the costs would arrive much sooner.
If Ghana reached net zero in 2050 and maintained it while every other country continued with current policies, global temperatures in 2100 would be just 0.00554°C lower, according to the model.
The cost to Ghana would be GH¢852 billion in 2045 alone. Between 2027 and 2100, the total would reach GH¢20.9 trillion in today’s money, while the estimated global climate benefit would be GH¢920 billion – around 4% of the cost.
On a worldwide basis, net zero by 2050 is calculated to prevent $24 trillion in climate damage this century, but at a cost of $255 trillion, also in today’s money.
Alternative priorities
The analysis says fossil fuels remain relatively cheap and widely available, helping explain why they still provide more than four-fifths of global energy and why emissions rose again last year.
At the rate of change seen over the past half-century, it argues fossil fuels would not disappear by 2050, but by 2997.
The article suggests early-warning systems and stronger bridges would protect people in Nepal more quickly and cheaply than climate policies agreed at COP31. The summit president has pointed to the August glacier flood in Nepal, which killed more than 1,400 people, as evidence of climate change’s consequences.
It also argues that reducing poverty would make people in Nepal and elsewhere less vulnerable to climate impacts.
The writer is President of Copenhagen Consensus, a Visiting Fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, and author of False Alarm and Best Things First.