Spanish referee Jose Luis Munuera Montero says officials are being unfairly blamed for decisions they are responsible only for applying, while revealing that artificial intelligence selects the controversial incidents shown on the Review Time programme.
Munuera and fellow referee Jorge Figueroa Vazquez were speaking at a meeting organised by the Sports Journalists Association in Seville, reported by Spanish radio station Cadena SER.
“We believe in accuracy and commitment. We are required to meet very high standards and have very little margin for error,” Munuera said.
“Unfortunately, people do not understand that the referee is not the person committing the offences. We are responsible for applying the rules set out by The International Football Association Board for their interpretation.”
He added: “Until supporters understand that we are not the guilty parties, the situation will remain extremely difficult. Everyone is responsible for their own actions, whether that is a penalty or a red card. We work hard to preserve our credibility on the pitch.”
Munuera said greater openness could help improve relations between referees, players and supporters.
“Transparency helps all of us understand each other better. If we make a mistake, we are the ones who face the greatest consequences,” he said.
“We have a points system and defined criteria. There is extensive assessment of the technical, physical, psychological and disciplinary aspects. Constructive criticism improves our performance.”
The referee said some players and managers were highly knowledgeable about the laws of the game and that officials were willing to explain their decisions.
“There are players who surprise us with their understanding of the rules and their ability to debate, just as many managers do,” Munuera said. “We are the first people who want to explain the criteria we applied on the field.”
He added that modern refereeing was becoming more open, although direct communication was not always appropriate.
“We want players to communicate with us, but sometimes that is not the best approach. We know the players well, and they know us,” he said.
Munuera then disclosed that the clips selected for Review Time are not chosen by people.
“The incidents for the Review Time programme are selected by artificial intelligence; nobody chooses them,” he said. “We are trying to reach as many people as possible. We give interviews and attend events so that everyone can understand how we work.”
He said referees needed more opportunities on radio and television to explain their decisions and reach a wider audience.
Figueroa Vazquez also addressed the controversy involving Real Madrid and Sevilla at Santiago Bernabeu, concerning Guler and Bikey.
“There are incidents that are not clear enough for a decision to be made,” he said.
“If you see an image where you cannot establish whether the ball hit his chest, hand or shoulder, those cameras do not provide sufficient clarity. They do not offer the guarantees needed to make a decision under the protocol. That is a question for the television production team.”
Spanish refereeing is under intense pressure, with disputes over decisions increasing each round and criticism coming from clubs and supporters.
Munuera believes greater transparency and communication are needed to show that referees are human, can make mistakes, but do not make them deliberately. Both officials said their priority remained protecting the game, applying the laws fairly and preserving the credibility of the competition.